The Upside Of Unrequited

In 2015, 17-year-old twins Molly and Cassie live with their two moms in Takoma Park, Maryland. Cassie is flirty and fearless, while Molly is shy with frequent unrequited crushes. Their moms plan their wedding after the Supreme Court rules for marriage equality. Cassie, absorbed in her new relationship with Mina, leaves Molly feeling alone. Mina introduces Molly to Will, who seems perfect. Meanwhile, Molly's coworker Reid, an awkward Tolkien fan, also catches her interest, leaving her torn between them.