John Cariani's New Play 'Darker the Night Brighter the Stars' Begins Casting at The Public Theatre in Lewiston, Maine

Fans of John Cariani's beloved "Almost, Maine" will want to pay close attention to what's developing up in Lewiston. The Public Theatre has announced "Darker the Night Brighter the Stars," a new full-length play from Cariani that returns to the emotional landscape of Northern Maine and centers on a younger generation of residents navigating love, identity, and the defining crossroads of early adulthood. The production is currently in casting and pre-production, with a rehearsal and performance run scheduled from January 4 through January 31, 2027. For actors, stage managers, and theatre technicians in the New England region, this is one to pursue now.

Cariani is one of the most produced playwrights in American community and regional theatre, and for good reason. "Almost, Maine," which premiered in 2004 and has since become one of the most frequently staged plays in the United States at both the professional and educational level, established him as a writer with a rare gift for blending tenderness, humor, and structural ingenuity. That piece used a similar format to what "Darker the Night Brighter the Stars" appears to employ: a series of two-person scenes set in the same rural Maine world, each story standing alone while contributing to a larger emotional whole. Here, four actors will play multiple characters across a variety of vignettes, with all characters written as young adults in their late teens to early twenties. The material encompasses coming out, first love, enlisting in the military, heading off to college, and the bittersweet act of moving on. It's the kind of play that asks a lot of its small cast in terms of range, and that makes the casting process particularly worth watching.

Directing the production is Janet Mitchko, who also serves as Artistic Director of The Public Theatre. Mitchko has been a steady and committed steward of Maine's regional theatre landscape and brings genuine institutional knowledge of how to serve Cariani's style of work. When a playwright of Cariani's stature develops a new piece at a regional house where the artistic director also directs, that's a strong signal of a close creative collaboration and a production environment built around the work itself rather than commercial pressures. Casting is being handled in-house by The Public Theatre, so actors and their representatives should direct inquiries directly to the company rather than to an outside casting office.

The Public Theatre is Lewiston's flagship professional theatre company and has been a cornerstone of the performing arts in Maine for decades. As a small-to-mid-size regional nonprofit, it punches above its weight creatively, and its association with Cariani, who is a Maine native, reflects the kind of home-state connection that often produces especially charged and personal work. Lewiston itself is Maine's second-largest city and sits in Androscoggin County in the western part of the state, roughly 35 miles north of Portland. For performers and crew based in Maine, New Hampshire, or the greater Boston area, the geography is manageable. The production will almost certainly operate under an Actors' Equity Association agreement appropriate to a LORT or SPT-tier regional house, though prospective talent should confirm the specific contract with the theatre directly.

In terms of production scale, this is an intimate piece by design. Four actors, a series of two-person scenes, and a production likely built around strong performances and a flexible, evocative design aesthetic rather than large-scale spectacle. That said, the design team will have interesting creative challenges to solve. A play structured around multiple short scenes set in a unified Northern Maine world will require a scenic concept that can shift fluidly without disrupting the play's rhythm, and a lighting designer who can help paint those shooting-star moments with real atmosphere. Costume design, while not elaborate, will need to distinguish multiple characters across four actors with efficiency and clarity. For stage managers, props masters, and sound designers working at the regional level in New England, this is the kind of production that rewards craft and collaboration.

With a start date of January 4, 2027, there is time to plan, but casting at regional theatres for early-year productions often moves sooner than people expect, particularly when a playwright of Cariani's profile is involved and the role pool is deliberately small. Four actors means four slots, and the theatre will want to lock in the right ensemble well in advance of rehearsals. Actors pursuing this project should not wait. For technical and design roles, outreach to the production office in Lewiston is worth beginning now as well. The full production listing, including contact information for The Public Theatre and any additional crew details as they are confirmed, is available at ProductionList.com. Bookmark it, check back regularly, and make your move early on this one.

Click here for production info or to contact producers